Notifications
Clear all

MIDI BOX BUG passing MIDI through

5 Posts
2 Users
0 Likes
782 Views
(@ro-mix)
Estimable Member
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 111
Topic starter  

Look an MIDI log, first five notes are without MIDI BOX ON, next 5 - same notes but after passing MIDI BOX. This results HANGING NOTES
0.00 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 0
0.00 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 0
2121.42 ms: Ch01 Note on D4 nn 74 vel 103
2295.60 ms: Ch01 Note off D4 nn 74
2495.06 ms: Ch01 Note on E4 nn 76 vel 103
2634.42 ms: Ch01 Note off E4 nn 76
2849.77 ms: Ch01 Note on F4 nn 77 vel 105
2976.90 ms: Ch01 Note off F4 nn 77
3198.52 ms: Ch01 Note on G4 nn 79 vel 105
3333.67 ms: Ch01 Note off G4 nn 79
3593.10 ms: Ch01 Note on A4 nn 81 vel 92
3749.65 ms: Ch01 Note off A4 nn 81

------------
20245.33 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
20245.33 ms: Ch01 Note on D3 nn 62 vel 77
20249.00 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
20250.48 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 127
20250.48 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
20250.67 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 127
20250.67 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
20432.00 ms: Ch01 Note off D3 nn 62
20432.00 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
20602.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
20602.67 ms: Ch01 Note on E3 nn 64 vel 77
20606.33 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
20607.81 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 127
20607.81 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
20608.00 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 127
20608.00 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
20730.67 ms: Ch01 Note off E3 nn 64
20730.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
20938.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
20938.67 ms: Ch01 Note on F3 nn 65 vel 77
20942.33 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
20943.81 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 127
20943.81 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
20944.00 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 127
20944.00 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
21050.67 ms: Ch01 Note off F3 nn 65
21050.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
21264.00 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
21264.00 ms: Ch01 Note on G3 nn 67 vel 77
21267.67 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
21269.15 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 127
21269.15 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
21269.33 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 127
21269.33 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
21370.67 ms: Ch01 Note off G3 nn 67
21370.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
21632.00 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
21632.00 ms: Ch01 Note on A3 nn 69 vel 77
21635.67 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
21637.15 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 127
21637.15 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
21637.33 ms: Ch01 CC51 ([51]): 127
21637.33 ms: Ch01 CC53 ([53]): 127
21802.67 ms: Ch01 Note off A3 nn 69
21802.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0


   
Quote
(@ro-mix)
Estimable Member
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 111
Topic starter  

Some bugs appear after some time playing with MIDI BOX, f.e now one of midiboxes started to send only Pedal CC on every recieved note
Note off E4 nn 76
642483.67 ms: Ch01 Note on F4 nn 77 vel 94
642679.62 ms: Ch01 Note off F4 nn 77
642846.42 ms: Ch01 Note on G4 nn 79 vel 95
643040.42 ms: Ch01 Note off G4 nn 79
643191.00 ms: Ch01 Note on A4 nn 81 vel 96
643398.23 ms: Ch01 Note off A4 nn 81
--- MIDI BOX ON
644617.33 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
644617.33 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
644958.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
644958.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
645246.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
645246.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
645518.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
645518.67 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0
645764.00 ms: Ch01 CC64 (Hold Pedal (on/off)): 0

And in one shot mode on key pressed after loop is finished - midi loop does not start again.. what actually the use of this mode if it can play once for an arrangement - but it is not single shot midi sample because one shot means it plays completely on keypress and stops. And on a next press again it plays all loop and stops. Now track with this mode can be used only once per arrangement, so if i assigned a button to a oneshot midi lopp - i loose this button after shooting loop...

And loop on a key mode functions almost the same as a loop mode. IMO It should differ from loop mode - playing file from a first note as in Oneshot mode, more consistent behaviour

This post was modified 1 year ago 2 times by RO-mix

   
ReplyQuote
(@getdunne)
Illustrious Member Admin
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 3907
 

@ro-mix

Please post your test patch and MIDI file.


   
ReplyQuote
(@ro-mix)
Estimable Member
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 111
Topic starter  

@getdunne Stacking notes occure when i play LEGATO through MIDI BOX. Probably becuse of pedal Hold messages (i don know where from they come)
https://mega.nz/file/3XAUSTpL#rInEb2PTP45te2zIk6MQ3tRO-L7ghKtl6VuTSdPMu5o

This post was modified 1 year ago 2 times by RO-mix

   
ReplyQuote
(@getdunne)
Illustrious Member Admin
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 3907
 

@ro-mix

This is a very complex patch. So complex, in fact, that I can't even guess what you're trying to do. The embedded Unify instance uses an additional MIDI file which you didn't include, and several third-party plug-ins. Could you possibly try to whittle this patch down to the simplest version that still illustrates the issue?


   
ReplyQuote
Share: